Sturgeon bones re-identified here based on Wuttagoonaspis and document the migration of the nose around the skull

Yesterday
the skull bone diagram of Middle Devonian Wuttagoonaspis (Fig 1) helped re-identify the enigmatic and largely fused skull bones of other jawless heterostracans.

Figure 2. Two species of Middle Devonian Wuttagoonaspis. Colors added here.
Figure 1. Wuttagoonaspis. The nasals (pink) wrapp the skull perimeter.

Today
the same Wuttagoonaspis diagram (Fig 1) helped re-identify the enigmatic mosaic of skull bones found in sturgeons (Fig 2)… if valid.

Applying tetrapod homologs to fish skulls
is done here (Figs 1, 2) to provide a common identity for scoring all vertebrates in the large reptile tree (LRT, 2306 taxa). In this way bones are free to fuse and fracture, but by giving them colors their homologs to tetrapod skull bones remain constant for scoring in the LRT.

Presently
This is a hypothesis of methodology that requires confirmation, refutation or modification by other workers.

Figure 1. Acipenser skulls from Hilton 2005 and re-colored here.
Figure 2. Acipenser skulls from Hilton 2005 and re-colored here.

You’ll note the nares
of Wuttagoonaspis are ventral (not visible in figure 1), while those of the sturgeon Acipenser are lateral and confluent with the orbit. Intermediate taxa not tested in the LRT may be unknown at present. Taxon suggestions for this problem are welcome.

Figure 5. Two extant sturgeons, Acipenser and Pseudoscaphirhynchus, compared to the extinct heterostracan, Hemicyclaspis, a close relative to Zenaspis in figure 4.
Figure 3. (Middle and bottom) two extant sturgeons, Acipenser and Pseudoscaphirhynchus, compared to the extinct heterostracan, Hemicyclaspis (top), a close relative to Wuttagoonaspis (Fig 1).

To make matters worse
in the LRT more primitive taxa have terminal nares, or a single naris, located dorsally, migrating anterior to short snout from an original position between the eyes in Metaspriggina (Fig 4) in the Cambrian.

Figure 4. Metaspriggina is the most primitive taxon with a pair of eyeballs with lenses.
Figure 4. Metaspriggina is the most primitive taxon with a pair of eyeballs with lenses.

So the migration of the naris in basal chordates is a complex problem
awaiting a solution that can be resolved with more transitional taxa that illustrate the journey of the nose around the skull in smaller, more discrete steps that those shown here (Figs 1–4).

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.