Today’s post
was prompted by running across the above headline and website. It was updated Novermber 8, 2023 after a second origin of jaws split bony fish prior to the origin of bony fish a few days earlier.
Reported by Anietra Hamper in 2019 under the title:
“Fish Finds: Uncovering the Origins of the Catfish Family Tree” and the subhead: “How evolutionary biologists are using nearly 50-million-year-old fossils for insight into the origins and evolution of catfish.”
The featured taxon
was Middle Eocene Hypsidoris farsonensis (Lundberg and Case 1970, Figs 1, 2), which was subsequently added to the large reptile tree (LRT, 1227 taxa). Unlike many catfish, Hypsidoris retains a toothless bit of loose maxilla.
The featured expert
was Dr Lance Grande, Field Museum, Chicago, USA, who redescribed Hypsidoris in 1986.
Hamper et al. 2019 reported,
“The telltale characteristics of catfish – peculiar denticular pectoral and dorsal spines, the lack of scales on the body, cat-like whiskers, the lack of maxiilary teeth in most species, and exceptional sensory ability, fascinate evolutionary biologists as much as they do the passionate anglers who are drawn to the living versions of catfish today.”
Be careful. Taxa are defined by their phylogenetic ancestors, not their traits.
“The only other catfishes that have a well-developed maxilla with teeth today are species in the South American family, Diplomystidae.”
With that bit of info, Diplomystes (Figs 3, 4) was likewise added to the LRT.
Teeth on the maxilla
sounds like it should be primitive. That makes sense, but it’s “Pulling a Larry Martin.“
Adding taxa
nests catfish with Guiyu, Dialipina and Loganellia among Silurian taxa.
According to the LRT
(Fig 5) the toothy catfish, Diplomystes (Figs 3,4) is not the most primitive catfish. Rather, with the presently tested list, toothless, maxilla-less catfish that more closely resemble Clarias are more primitive. The maxilla of catfish is not homologous with the maxilla of tetrapod ancestors going back to Lasanius and Birkenia.
It is possible
that teeth re-evolved in toothy catfish. More likely: catfish had a long ghost lineage back to the Late Devonian not currently represented in the fossil record. Those catfish clades radiated in the meantime.
The LRT documents the ancestry of all included taxa
back to Ediacaran worms. Adding taxa resolves all phylogenetic problems.
If you go to university
you will learn exactly what they teach out of an approved, but outdated textbook.
Instead, if you want to learn as much as you can about evolution,
do the work. Build your own LRT. Learn the way things really are and were. Workers won’t like your independence, and you may be ostracized, but you’ll sooner or later understand what they don’t and won’t teach at the university level.
The top six problems in paleontology:
Number one: taxon exclusion.
Number two: borrowing untested cladograms.
Number three: trusting genomic results.
Number four: trusting textbooks and academic traditions.
Number five: freehand reconstructions.
Number six: “Pulling a Larry Martin” = focusing on one to a dozen traits, rather than a complete suite.
Solution: Keep adding taxa to your own trait-based cladogram. Trace specimens with transparent colors and from those tracings create more accurate and verifiable reconstructions.
References
Grande L 1986. Redescription of Hypsidoris farsonensis (Teleostei: Siluriformes), with a reassessment of its phylogenetic relationships. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 7:24–54.
Lundberg JG and Case GR 1970. A New Catfish from the Eocene Green River Formation, Wyoming. Journal of Paleontology. 44 (3): 452.
Xu G-H 2019. Osteology and phylogeny of Robustichthys luopingensis, the largest holostean fish in the Middle Triassic. PeerJ doi: 10.7717/peerj.7184. eCollection 2019.
wiki/Hypsidoris
planetcatfish.com/common/genus.php?genus_id=290
prehistoric-wildlife.com/species/h/hypsidoris.html
wiki/Lance_Grande
wiki/Diplomystes_camposensis
The Pterosaur Heresies 