Related mammals that nest at the bases of several hoofed clades

The value
of the large reptile tree (LRT, 1013 taxa) and the reconstructions gathered together at ReptileEvolution.com lie in their ability to put faces on names (Figs, 1) sometimes to scale (Fig. 2) to help one recognize patterns that may have gone unrecognized while just looking at names and scores.

These are the mammals that nest with one another
as sisters after deletion of more derived taxa in each of their several clades (listed at right, Fig. 1). Thus they, more or less, represent the basal radiation of hoofed mammals prior to each clade radiation. And to no one’s surprise, they look like each other, despite wide variations in size.

Frankly,
I’m reexamining the traits of these taxa because the LRT had trouble resolving them. There were mistakes in there. Now, after some score corrections, the resolution is complete again, but some Bootstrap scores have risen to just above 50. Not great, but better than below 50. Remember, I don’t have access to these specimens and sometimes work from published drawings.

Figure 1. Skulls of taxa nesting at the bases of several mammal clades starting with mesonychids.

Figure 1. Skulls of taxa nesting at the bases of several mammal clades starting with mesonychids. The differences are harder to see than in derived taxa in each clade (column at right). See figure 2 for skeletons to scale.

Some of these basal taxa
gave rise to baleen whales. Others were ancestral to giraffes, elephants, horses and everything in between. None of these taxa are nearly so famous or interesting to the general public, but it is from these generalized (plesiomorphic) taxa that the few and subtle evolutionary changes that are key to each clade first make an appearance.

Figure 2. Skeletons of taxa basal to various clades derived from basal mesonychids, all to scale.

Figure 2. Skeletons of taxa basal to various clades derived from basal mesonychids, all to scale. Note the presence of phylogenetic miniaturization at the base of the Artiodactyla. Consider this scenario: mesonychids radiated widely, including to create larger and smaller taxa. The larger homalotheres did not radiate greatly, as far as we know. On the other hand, the smaller taxa radiated to become a long list of extinct and exact hoofed taxa. And, of course, the mesonychid clade radiated to include today’s hippos and baleen whales. 

Sometimes a ‘show and tell’ drives a point home
better than just a ‘tell’. Even so, these are not the precise individuals in the direct lineage of known derived taxa, but the close relatives of those perhaps eternally unknown and hypothetical individuals. The suite of traits that lump and separate these taxa can be gleaned from the present MacClade file, continually added to and updated, and available here., which is where you can also see the cladogram from which the above taxa were pulled.

 

Lambdotherium: not a basal brontothere — it’s another pig relative!

Earlier a putative stem brontothere, Danjiangia, was re-nested with basal artiodactyls in the large reptile tree (LRT, 1005 taxa).

Here another putative stem brontothere,
Lambdotherium (Cope 1880, Mader 1998; Eocene, 50mya; Fig. 1) likewise moves away from the basal brontothere, Eotitanops. In the LRT  Lambdotherium nests with Ancodus (Fig. 2), another basal artiodactyl close to extant pigs.

Figure 1. Lambdotherium traditionally nests with the basal brontothere, Eotitanops, but here nests with Ancodus, a basal artiodactyl.

Figure 1. Lambdotherium traditionally nests with the basal brontothere, Eotitanops (ghosted here), but here nests with Ancodus, a basal artiodactyl. Brontotheres have a very tall naris. Pigs do not. 

I don’t know of any post-crania
for Lambdotherium. Note that Ancodus (Fig. 2), like Eotitanops, has a pentadatyl manus. Lambdotherium was traditionally considered a brontothere based on its teeth. The LRT employs relatively few dental traits. And maybe some specimens need to be reexamined. The very high arch of the Lambdotherium squamosal, among many other traits, is more similar to pig-like taxa, than to basal brontotheres, which here nest closer to rhinos, than to horses, contra the Wikipedia report on brontotheres.

Distinct from both rhinos and horses,
brontotheres have four toes on the forefeet. All are derived from a sister to Hyrachyus, which likewise has four toes.

Figure 1. Ancodus nests as a more derived sister to Sus and it retains digit 1 on the manus and pes.

Figure 2. Ancodus nests as a more derived sister to Sus and it retains digit 1 on the manus and pes.

References
Cope ED 1880. The bad lands of the Wind River and their fauna. The American Naturalist 14(10):745-748.
Mader BJ 1998. Brontotheriidae. In Janis CM, Scott KM, and Jacobs LL (eds.), Evolution of Tertiary Mammals of North America 1:525-536.
Mihlbachler MC 2004. Phylogenetic Systematics of the Brontotheriidae (Mammalia, Perissodactyla). PhD dissertation. Columbia University. p. 757.
Mihlbachler MC 2008. Species taxonomy, phylogeny and biogeography of teh Brontotheriidae (Mammalia: Perissodactyla). Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 311:475pp.

wiki/Eotitanops
wiki/Lambdotherium

Splitting up the Ungulates

Get ready for a good dose of heresy
brought to you by the large reptile tree (LRT 1003 taxa) a fully resolved online morphological study.

A little backstory
According to Wikipedia: Ungulates are any members of a diverse group of primarily large mammals that includes odd-toed ungulates such as horses and rhinoceroses, and even-toed ungulates such as cattlepigsgiraffescamelsdeer, and hippopotami.”

“However, in 2009 morphological and molecular[ work has found that aardvarks, hyraxes, sea cows, and elephants are more closely related to sengistenrecs, and golden moles than to the perissodactyls and artiodactyls, and form Afrotheria. Elephants, sea cows, and hyraxes are grouped together in the clade Paenungulata, while the aardvark has been considered as either a close relative to them or a close relative to sengis in the clade Afroinsectiphilia. This is a striking example of convergent evolution.

“There is now some dispute as to whether this smaller Ungulata is a cladistic (evolution-based) group, or merely a pheneticgroup (form taxon) or folk taxon (similar, but not necessarily related). Some studies have indeed found the mesaxonianungulates and paraxonian ungulates to form a monophyletic lineage, closely related to either the Ferae (the carnivorans and the pangolins) in the clade Fereuungulata or to the bats. Other studies found the two orders not that closely related, as some place the perissodactyls as close relatives to bats and Ferae in Pegasoferae and others place the artiodactyls as close relatives to bats.” 

About that last hypothesis ~
If I had recovered that relationship I would expect pitchforks and torches.

Today
the LRT presents a hypothesis of mammal relationships in which hippos nest apart from other artiodactyls and perissodactyls nest apart from those two, separated by the elephant/hyrax/manatee clade with the hyrax-like Ectocion at it base (Fig. 1).

Figure 1. Subset of the LRT focusing on ungulates, which split into three clades here.

Figure 1. Subset of the LRT focusing on ungulates, which split into three clades here.

Note:
Hippos do indeed nest with whales, but only the mysticete whales. And desmostylians separate hippos from mysticetes. Odontocetes, like Orcinus, had a separate ancestry as we learned earlier here. The even-toed artiodactyls nest together with pig-types toward the base and deer-types a little later. The odd-toed perissodactyls nest together.

There are no
tenrecs, aardvarks or golden moles in this sector of the LRT.

Ungulata is not a monophyletic cladistic group,
unless it also includes the elephants and whales with Mesonyx as a basal member, (a taxon close to the last common ancestor). I’m not the first one to come to this conclusion. Probably best just to drop this name from usage and realize that hooves appeared several times in mammal evolution.

A little extra study
cleared up the earlier Pappaceras issue. Now the nesting is more in accord with consensus with regard to the indricotheres, but they’re still closer to 3-toed horses than to 3-toed rhinos.

Also note:
the <50 Bootstrap scores surrounding Hyracotherum, a basal horse/rhino. I could only separate sister taxa by 2 steps. It takes at least 3 steps to bounce the Boostrap score over 50. Small steps. Small steps.