Some confusion in the academic literature today
as a Middle Jurassic fossil known since the 19th century is grossly misidentified.
Today a paper by O’Sullivan and Martill 2018
redescribes several fossils from the Middle Jurassic (165–166 mya) of England, traditionally ascribed to the wastebasket pterosaur taxon, Rhamphocephalus prestwichi (type, Seeley, 1880; OUM J.28266; Figs. 1–4). Most of the disassociated specimens (individual jaws, limbs) are clearly pterosaurian. One (the goose-sized skull roof) is clearly not pterosaurian.
The holotype of Rhamphocephalus prestwichi,
“an isolated skull table, is found to be a misidentified crocodylomorph skull,” according to O’Sullivan and Martill, who illustrated the 10x smaller specimen alongside a dorsal view of the 3m long thalattosuchian (marine) croc, Pelagosaurus, from the Lower Jurassic of England and, perhaps to cover all their bases, flipped anterior-to-posterior alongside the Paleocene choristodere, Simoedosaurus (Fig. 2). Note: the authors did not illustrate their comparative taxa to scale (as shown above), perhaps because the taxa are 10x larger and are morphologically dissimilar. So why make such comparisons? I don’t understand the logic of these paleontologists making such readily disprovable comparisons.
using DGS methods (Fig. 3) and phylogenetically tested in the large reptile tree (LRT, 1321 taxa) goose-sized Rhamphocephalus nests with the hummingbird-sized, Hongshanornis (Fig. 2), an Early Cretaceous toothed bird from China. Hongshanornis is one of the few toothed birds in which the orbits are further forword, creating a longer cranium to match that of Rhamphocephalus. A suite of other skull traits are likewise most closely matched to Hongshanornis. The Rhamphocephlaus specimen appears to be complete without obvious breaks either at the toothy tip of the skull or the occiput. More teeth and bones were identified here.
the authors report, “The earliest known record of Bathonian pterosaurs is an account of “fossil bird bones” from the Taynton Limestone Formation of Stonesfield by an anonymous author A.B., appearing in the March edition of the Gentleman’s Magazine of 1757.” For this specimen, and only this specimen, A.B. got it right. The other specimens are clearly pterosaurian.
the authors report, “This specimen is exposed on a limestone slab in dorsal view and was assigned to Pterosauria based on its perceived thin bone walls. Seeley (1880) noted that the arrangement of bones was more crocodilian than pterosaurian and considered this construction diagnostic of the new taxon. Significantly he (Seeley 1880: 30) stated: “I shall be quite prepared to find that all the ornithosaurians from Stonesfield belong to this or an allied genus which had Rhamphorhynchus for its nearest ally.” In the LRT crocodilians are closer to birds than pterosaurs are.
Is the Middle Jurassic too early for a toothed bird?
Perhaps not. Remembet that all of the Late Jurassic Solnhofen birds, traditionally named as one genus, Archaeopteryx, already represent a diverse radiation of taxa, suggesting an earlier genesis for that radiation. Rhamphocephalus indicates that the original bird radiation had its genesis at least 15 million years earlier.
It is unfortunate
that O’Sullivan and Martill attempted to force fit the skull specimen into a crocodilian clade when no aspect of the thin-walled, goose-sized skull of Rhamphocephalus is crocodilian (Fig. 2)… or choristoderan (when flipped backwards!!). Adding Rhamphocephalus to the LRT gives it a single most parsimonious sister among all the toothed birds and a special Middle Jurassic place in the origin of birds story. All the details fit.
Working with a high-resolution image
of Rhamphocephalus (Fig. 3) copied from a PDF of the paper by O’Sullivan and Martill made this all possible.
Once again, to determine the affinities of a specimen it is more important to have a wide gamut of taxa to work with than to have firsthand access to the specimen itself. No one likes this method, but it clearly works time after time and to not use it invites discredit.
USE THE LRT. That’s what it is here for.
O’Sullivan M and Martill DM 2018. Pterosauria of the Great Oolite Group (Bathonian, Middle Jurassic) of Oxfordshire and Gloucestire. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 63 (X): xxx–xxx, 2018 https://doi.org/10.4202/app.00490.2018
Seeley HG 1880. On Rhamphocephalus prestwichi Seeley, an Ornithosaurian from the Stonesfield Slate of Kineton. Quart. J. Geol. Soc. 36: 27-30.