Meiolania eggs confirm basal turtle status

Earlier the horned turtles, Meiolania and Niolamia, were nested in the large reptile tree (LRT) as basalmost hardshell turtles, closely related to the toothed horned stem turtle/pareiasaur, Elginia. This was heresy when introduced.

newly discovered turtle eggs (Lawver and Jackson 2016) add evidence to the basal status of Meiolania.

From the Lawver and Jackson 2016 abstract:
“A fossil egg clutch from the Pleistocene of Lord Howe Island, Australia that we assign to Testudoolithus lordhowensis, oosp. nov. belongs to the stem turtle Meiolania platyceps.  Thin sections and scanning electron microscopy demonstrate that these eggs are composed of radiating acicular aragonite crystals. This mineral composition first evolved either before the split between Meiolaniformes and crown Testudines or prior to Proterochersis robusta, the earliest known stem turtle. Meiolania platyceps deposited its eggs inside an excavated hole nest. This nesting strategy likely evolved no later than the Early to Middle Jurassic.”

All known meiolanids
are from later, higher Late Cretaceous and Tertiary strata.

Figure 5. Meiolania, the most primitive of known turtles, has lateral forelimbs, like non turtles.

Figure 1. Meiolania, one of the most primitive of known hard-shell turtles, has lateral forelimbs, like non turtles. All extant turtles have anteriorly-directed humeri. It also had cranial horns, like the toothed pareiasaur/turtle? Elginia.

At present,
soft-shell and hard-shell turtles have a dual origin from separate small Late Permian and Middle Triassic pareiasaur ancestors, Elginia and Sclerosaurus. Both were also horned. The traditional earliest known turtles, Proganochelys and Odontochelys are both known from later, Late Triassic, strata.

Not on topic, but worth watching on YouTube:
Here’s a video about the origin of oil in the Jurassic. It runs for 90 minutes and is fascinating throughout. The video reminds us what a recent Golden Age we currently live in based on a limited supply of petroleum products. The video concludes we have long passed the tipping point for climate change based on the flood of cheap energy. And the end of the oil age is something our children will see. Ironically, climate change in the ice-free Jurassic was one factor in the Earth producing the oil we now use.

Lawver DR and Jackson FD 2016. A fossil egg clutch from the stem turtle Meiolania platyceps: implications for the evolution of turtle reproductive biology. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. DOI: 10.1080/02724634.2016.1223685.

2 thoughts on “Meiolania eggs confirm basal turtle status

  1. You completely misinterpreted this paper. Non-crown meiolaniids weren’t heresy when you recovered them as such last year. This was found at least as early as Dryden (1998), and while Gaffney didn’t recover it, it has been supported by Joyce’s (2007) landmark analysis, Anquetin’s (2012), and others. It’s you putting Meiolania outside Proganochelys+living turtles that’s the heresy (and the whole Trionyx thing). This paper merely uses the stem position as found by those earlier papers to propose modern turtle characters like aragonitic eggshells emerged on the turtle stem, since they were found in Meiolania. But the fact Meiolania has these modern characters means they would be equally well explained if it was a cryptodire like Gaffney believed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.