According to the cladogram
of the large reptile tree the proximal outgroup to Archaeopteryx and the flapping birds includes Eosinopteryx (Godefroit et al. 2013, Middle-Late Jurassic, Tiaojishan Formation, YFGP-T5197, 30 cm, 12 in long) and Xiaotingia (Figs. 1-4; Xu et al. 2011, STM 27-2). This nesting has not changed despite the addition of several very bird-like theropod taxa recently (some listed below) to the large reptile tree.
Although they both had large wing feathers,
only Xiaotingia had tall coracoids. Coracoids were narrow, but short in Eosinopteryx. Tall coracoids are morphological signs that an extinct taxon was flapping.
Tall coracoids first appear
in the true bird lineage with the basalmost Archaeopteryx, the Thermopolis specimen (Fig. 5).
and along with Xiaotingia, tall-ish coracoids also appear in the unrelated pseudo bird-like taxa Microraptor + Sinornithosaurus and Velociraptor + Balaur. Evidently they were flapping too.
The Thermopolis specimen
of Archaeopteryx (Fig. 5) has the shortest and smallest coracoids of the Solnhofen birds. Note the basal troodontid (Fig. 7) proportions of the small skull and long tail, distinct from the larger skulls and shorter tails in the clade that includes Xiaotingia and Eosinopteryx.
By contrast and convergence,
and based on the reduction of their coracoids to struts, prevolant pterosaur ancestors, like Cosesaurus (Fig. 6), were flapping millions of generations before this clade had anything resembling wings,
Many workers nest
microraptors and velociraptors closer to birds. At least part of that nesting includes the presence of feathers and tall narrow coracoids, ideal for flapping. Unfortunately these alternate nestings cannot be confirmed by the large reptile tree that nest small troodontids, like Xiaotiingia and Eosinopteryx, basal to birds. At least one prior analysis was riddled with errors. I have not examined others yet.
This is where software comes in handy,
finding most parsimonious trees based on a long list of traits despite convergence in a few traits and making every attempt to keep paradigm and tradition out of every computation. These taxa were reexamined and discovered because the the coracoids did not match while so many other characters do match and nest them together. The coracoids still do not match on sisters Xiaotingia and Eosinopteryx, but several errors were repaired.
Godefroit P, Demuynck H, Dyke G, Hu D, Escuillié FO and Claeys P. 2013. Reduced plumage and flight ability of a new Jurassic paravian theropod from China. Nature Communications 4: 1394. doi:10.1038/ncomms2389
Xu X, You H, Du K and HanF-L 2011. An Archaeopteryx-like theropod from China and the origin of Avialae. Nature 475 (7357): 465–470.