Herbstosaurus pigmaeus CTES-PZ-1711 (late Jurassic) was originally described as a small dinosaur (Casamiquela 1975). All that is known of this specimen is a pelvis, limb and prepubis (ahhh, there’s a clue!). Ostrom (1978) more accurately identified Herbstosaurus as a pterosaur.
But what kind?
Galton 1981 considered Herbstosaurus a member of the “Pterodactyloidea.” Carroll 1988 narrowed that down to the Pterodactylidae. Wellnhofer 1991 suggested it was a more basal pterosaur, in view of the form of the pelvis. In Unwin 1996 considered it a basal member of the Dsungaripteroidea.
So, with so little consensus, what is Herbstosaurus?
there is not enough here to run Herbstosaurus through phylogenetic analysis using the large pterosaur tree. So Let’s see where trait analysis leads us.
Ilial processes obliquely angled:
Most derived pterosaurs have this except basal pterosaurs up to MCSNB 8950.
Five+ swept back sacrals not coosified:
Most basal pterosaurs have five sacrals not coossified. This does not mean they are juveniles, unless the fossil record is seriously skewed. There are several clades of chiefly larger pterosaurs that coossify the sacrals. Other large forms don’t. Apparently only germanodactylids and their many descendants have swept back sacral transverse processes (Fig. 2) and basal forms, like Germanodactylus rhamphastinus and kin, do not coossify the sacrals.
Prepubis fan shape perhaps without perforation:
The fan shape appears in several clades The perforation is seen in most pterosaurs, but absent in an unassociated few. Germanodactylus often has a fan-shaped prepubis.
Femur with right angle head and neck, but head axis not aligned with neck axis.
This is a tough one. I wondered, is there some breakage that would, if repaired, align the femoral head axis with the femoral neck axis in Herbstosaurus? I’ve only seen drawings (Fig. 1). In most pterosaurs the axis of the head of the femur is very closely aligned with the axis of the neck of the femur. Not so in Herbstosaurus, hence the concern.
Substantial. No tiny pterosaurs.
From the available evidence, Unwin 1996 was the most correct. Herbstosaurus is likely a large and primitive Germanodactylus-type pterosaur. Large taxa are already known from that clade. They are the elanodactylids (Fig. 4). Unfortunately what is known from the partial skeletons of those specimens does not overlap with the partial skeleton of Herbstosaurus. In any case, at present with these clues, this seems to be a “best match.”
Casamiquela RM 1975. Herbstosaurus pigmaeus (Coeluria, Compsognathidae) n. gen. n. sp. del Jurásic medio del Neuquén (Patagonia septentrional). Uno de los más pequeños dinosaurios conocidos [Herbstosaurus pigmaeus (Coeluria, Compsognathidae) n. gen. n. sp. from the Middle Jurassic of Neuquén (northern Patagonia). One of the smallest known dinosaurs]. Actas del Primer Congreso Argentino de Paleontologia y Bioestratigrafia, Tucumán 2:87-103.
Galton PM 1981. A rhamphorhynchoid pterosaur from the Upper Jurassic of North America. Journal of Paleontology 55(5):1117-1122.
Ostrom JH 1978. “The osteology of Compsognathus longipes Wagner”, Zitteliana, 4: 73-118.
Unwin DM 2003. On the phylogeny and evolutionary history of pterosaurs. In E. Buffetaut, J.-M. Mazin (eds.), Evolution and Palaeobiology of Pterosaurs, Geological Society of London, Special Publications 217:139-190